"General" PvP Rules Agreement

[Kadar]

G?n?ral_Argos Wrote:@ kadar : Why waisting your time trying some show off high heals on lks when it has nothing to do here.??How do you come to the conclusion that a 66+4 vit alch would get a 3k heal???Don't you see that the heal is 1545 on a 63 vit alch?

@krim
I didn't have the opportunity to find an alch with only 60-70 vit. I did however find both an LK and a sader. As I explained the amount that Swordie classes get healed is DOUBLE what a normal character heals for due to lvl 10 HP RECOV. Alchemists on the other hand have a skill (potion research) which gives them +50% heal in addition to the regular healing boost from throw pot. So a NORMAL HEAL would be ~2k at that vit (based on half of the doubled swordie class chars). When you add in the +50% from potion research it should be ~3k. Maybe there is a difference in the way it compounds? I have no idea how you got such a low number. It's obviously the low of your range but even then it's a lot lower than it should be. Did you not max potion research? Did you even use a white pot? Is there some sort of glitch which makes targets other than oneself heal for more? Does the HP modifier or HP factor variables have a factor in the way throw pot heals?

@bloody
Oh I'm sorry I didn't know we were talking about EDP all of a sudden. Saying that you think EDP is more broken than Potion Pitcher doesn't make Potion Pitcher any less broken. The rest of that post was about trying to avoid the slippery slope of banning everything. This thread is here so that doesn't happen. Oh and I sure hope everyone did understand what I was trying to say with that excerpt you quoted. It's that this isn't a SinX vs Creator thread. People will always say EDP is overpowered because they're sick of dying to it. What does cloaking have to do with Potion Pitcher? And btw it's not a comeback; It's a reaction to your obviously misguided interpretations to the purpose of this thread. It's for the sake of overall pvp balance that Potion Pitcher should be removed in pvp events.

You have more vit than my homunc and heal for about the same? Maybe there is some unknown homunc throw potion boost?

Also.. did anyone see how fast throw potion could be spammed? If by some freak occurrence throw potion heals alchemists less than other classes then the pure spammability of it still puts it ahead of the Acolyte heal skill. Even more so on high vit builds.