"General" PvP Rules Agreement

[GM-Pandora]

G?n?ral_Argos Wrote:

GM-Pandora Wrote:trying to count the number of potion thrown during a fight is tedious, a number of potion for the whole event should be set,

Why would it be more tedious to set a limit for fights instead of the whole event? You do that for the toh but, I never liked that idea.

Because you actually have to count them during the fight, with your eyes, and you have 2 PVPers to check at the same time? That's much more tedious than checking people at the start only, and at the start it can even be done via npc if one is written up.

@Kretzer last I checked EDP did not last 3 minutes...

I'm liking the 3 minute limit to fight, at most go to 5 minutes. Really, if you can't kill your opponent that has no healing item in 5 minutes then it's called a tie.

As for the sage converters, they're the product of a skill, not the skill itself.

And scrolls, well I'd still say forbid them if it was up to me, because it's simpler, if we wanna get into "let's accept these scrolls but not those" it gets overly complicated. It doesn't really say on a scroll if it's from kafra or not, some of the ones ayu listed are not kafra item, they're just sitting in the database with currently no way to obtain them, who knows what plan gravity has for them (selling in kafra shop or adding to a monster).

Overall it's important to have fair rules of course, but it's equally important to have easy rules, as in, doesn't take 2 hours to read all the fine prints and exceptions.

Also, not too hard for a GM to check, the more you leave it up to 'GM eyes' the more there is room for complaints. "I saw him use 6 pots", "No way I only used 5 like the rule says", "He hid for 11 seconds and not 10", etc. we're not machines, we don't see everything, so the less complicated the better.