What if...

[Ryxingeir]

I'd be a marionette, because they are really cute (like the one in the Dark Frame Card and not the one in the actual marionette card), and i like that whole idea about being an immortal spirit living in a doll ~

[Mrmeow x_X]

Well... I'd be... Jakk... or Xmas Jakk, he's cool, and I love The Nightmare Before Xmas which he awefully reminds off =P
Bloody Knight is pretty too 8)
Or Deviling, he's so lil' and evil'

[Shmanway]

Eclipse for the win =DD

Its a freaking...huge....blue...bunny =DD

[DoomBaby]

id have to say smokie.
i love watching them dance.

[SPIEGEL]

hehe i think about this thread, hehe
GM? LOL

[Ultima_Pi]

Deviling. Or Succubus.

Manifus knows why.

[clonnus]

hm tough one id prolly be... a hydra! i stay in one spot all the time except to eat or go to school and other necessities (my comp is like 3 feet from my bed)

[Muzzle]

I'd say baby garm, too. Because OMGPUPPY and whatnot. = )