you aren't exactly contributing to the discussion for saying that...
But like I said about alliances, if they were meant to be permanant, you wouldn't be able to remove and make new ones. That's all I was saying.
Seems like the arrangement was fair to me anyway, if you got half back. Also, why not have just asked them to help defend too. If you did, and they refused, then you should've figured it out beforehand.
All I'm saying is at this point, you're not offering a reason as to whether or not we should change guild castles, like the thread is supposed to be about. Your guildies said it too; if you wanna rant, stick to your guild forums.
I personally thought it wasn't cool, but it was smart. That's all. Don't rant on me.